Author Harinder Sikka Criticises Raazi Adaptation, Regrets Choosing Meghna Gulzar

Author Harinder Sikka has renewed his criticism of filmmaker Meghna Gulzar over the adaptation of his novel Calling Sehmat into the 2018 film Raazi, expressing regret over appointing her to direct the project. In a recent statement, Sikka alleged that the filmmaker significantly altered the original narrative, claiming the story was “twisted” in its cinematic version. According to him, the film deviated from the core intent of his book, which is based on the real-life story of an Indian spy operating in Pakistan during the 1971 India-Pakistan war.

Sikka argued that the adaptation diluted the patriotic essence of his work by presenting a more nuanced and, in his view, sympathetic portrayal of Pakistan. He maintained that this shift weakened the emotional and ideological impact he intended to convey through the novel. The author also pointed out that several key elements of the storyline were either modified or omitted, particularly in how the protagonist’s actions and motivations were depicted on screen.

The criticism marks a continuation of Sikka’s long-standing dissatisfaction with the film. He has previously claimed that he was not adequately consulted during the filmmaking process and was not shown the final cut before the film’s release, despite expectations of involvement. These concerns, he suggested, contributed to the disconnect between his original narrative and its cinematic interpretation.

Sikka’s remarks have resurfaced at a time when his work is again drawing attention, partly due to discussions surrounding his recent and upcoming projects. Reflecting on the collaboration, he admitted that appointing Gulzar as director was a decision he now views as a mistake. Despite the renewed controversy, Meghna Gulzar has not issued any public response to Sikka’s latest comments. Raazi, which starred Alia Bhatt in the lead role, had been both a critical and commercial success upon its release, even as debate over its creative liberties continues.